Pursuant to Chapter 4, Section 2, Article 5 of the West Virginia Code, the Commission on Special Investigations presents the Twenty-fifth Annual Report to the West Virginia Legislature. This Report covers the Commission’s activities from July 1, 2004 through June 30, 2005.
The Commission on Special Investigations is comprised of ten Legislators: Five Senators and five Delegates. The following Legislators represent the membership of the Commission on Special Investigations as of June 30, 2005:
Senate Appointed to Commission
|Earl Ray Tomblin - D (Co-Chairman)||1995|
|H. Truman Chafin - D||1999|
|Donna Boley - R||2001|
|William R. Sharpe - D||1997|
|Vic Sprouse - R||1998|
House Appointed to Commission
|Robert S. Kiss - D (Co-Chairman)||1998|
|Greg Howard - R||2005|
|Harold Michael - D||2001|
|Richard W. Staton - D||1998|
|Charles S. Trump IV - R||1993|
These Legislators are responsible for overseeing the Commission’s activities, which are discussed at length during Legislative Interim meetings held throughout the year. A quorum, which consists of a majority of the total authorized membership of the Commission, is necessary for the Commission to open or close an investigation or refer the matter to the appropriate committee if the subject does not fall under the Commission’s purview.
Staff members of the Commission on Special Investigations as of June 30, 2005:
|Gary W. Slater||Director|
|Douglas B. Atkinson||Assistant Director|
|Charles R. Bedwell||Investigator|
|Herbert R. Cogar||Investigator|
|Roy M. Hutchison II||Investigator|
|James S. Powers||Investigator|
|Steven E. Staton||Investigator|
|Lisa M. Wilkinson||Secretary/Investigative Aide|
During the investigative process, individuals in both the private and public sector provided information to Commission members and/or staff members. It would be difficult for the Commission on Special Investigations to perform its duties without the assistance these individuals provide.
Various County Prosecuting Attorneys, United States Attorneys and Assistant United States Attorneys have contributed their time and the resources of their offices in prosecuting individuals who have committed the felonies and misdemeanors evidenced by investigative activities reported on by this Commission. The assistance these offices provide is invaluable in the pursuance of justice.
During the course of this fiscal year, the Commission on Special Investigations opened 7 investigative files and closed 1 investigation. As of June 30, 2005, there were 75 active investigations. The Commission met 10 times between July 1, 2004 and June 30, 2005. During these meetings the Commission staff apprised members of the alleged wrongdoing by agencies, individuals and/or firms conducting business with the State of West Virginia. Commission members also reported matters presented to them by their constituents, State employees, other legislative commissions, committees and fellow legislators.
Various allegations and investigative matters were reported and discussed during these meetings. Approval by a majority vote of the members present was obtained as needed to open, close or refer the matter(s) to prosecutors and/or other authorities.
Among the matters presented were the following:
Continuing an investigation that began in May 2002, Commission investigators, joined by agents of the IRS and FBI, participated in a Federal Grand Jury investigation of public corruption related to the 2001 flooding of Wyoming and McDowell Counties. The investigation disclosed a wide range of criminal violations by former Assistant Superintendent of Schools Glenn Allen McClung and Charleston businessman Phillip
K. “Pork Chop” Booth. McClung, in exchange for directing stated business to Booth, received numerous kickbacks, including cash and gifts.
On February 28, 2005, Booth entered a plea of guilty to one count of Wire Fraud and one count of Engaging in an Illegal Monetary Transaction in the U. S. District Court in Charleston.
On May 23, 2005, McClung entered a plea of guilty to the offenses of Extortion and Filing a False Federal Income Tax Return. The court scheduled a sentencing hearing for both defendants in August 2005. Booth died of an apparent heart attack on June 19, 2005.
Allegations of Division of Highways’ employees soliciting and accepting bribes were received by the Commission during the summer of 2003. It was alleged that three employees of the District I Special Permit Section were actively soliciting bribes in exchange for the issuance of permits for oversize and overweight loads that should not have been issued. Permits were allegedly issued for loads that potentially damaged roads and bridges, and jeopardized highway safety. District I was the only District office that was authorized to issue permits through an automated system. All other District offices use a paper permitting process.
Subsequent interviews established that the District I employees had in fact solicited numerous gifts and gratuities from two major Charleston area crane rental companies, All Crane Rental and Maximum Crane Works. These companies had provided to the Highways employees’ gift certificates, clothing and concert tickets valued at several hundred dollars in exchange for what they believed to be preferential treatment. In addition meals were provided to the Highways workers by allowing them to charge numerous lunches and dinners on one company’s VISA card
Also confirmed by the Commission investigation was the fact that improper and dangerous loads had indeed been routinely permitted by the District I employees who could override the automated system when it identified a problem load. It was however, determined that the improper permitting was the result of a lack of training and oversight within the Permit Section and not an intentional act by the employees to allow unsafe loads on the highways. While the crane rental companies thought they were receiving preferential treatment in their requests for permits, in reality the Permit Section employees would have issued the permits anyway, believing they were in compliance with the guidelines of the Division.
As a result of the Commission investigation, Highways conducted an internal review of its permitting process, including training and oversight. This review resulted in the removal of the permitting process from District I and reassigning it to the Central Office. Additionally, changes were recommended for the automated permitting software to prevent future overrides in the system.
In September 2004, one of the District I employees entered into a plea agreement in Kanawha County whereby he pled to one count of Unlawful Rewarding for Past Behavior (Â§61-5A-4) and agreed to pay a fine and restitution. A jail term of 3 months was suspended and he was placed on probation for a term of 12 months.
Two additional employees are expected to plead to similar charges in coming months.
Gary Kitzmiller was hired as the County Supervisor for the Division of Highways (DOH) in Grant County in June 1997. Prior to Kitzmiller being hired as the DOH Grant County Supervisor, he was the owner/operator of a construction company known as “A.L.L. Construction.”
In May 2004, information was received by the Commission on Special Investigations that Gary Kitzmiller was running his private construction company
(A.L.L. Construction) and had a timbering business in Grant County. According to the information received, Kitzmiller was operating two private businesses while supposedly working during the day as the DOH Grant County Supervisor. According to the information received, Kitzmiller tried to conceal the fact that he owned the construction company by saying his wife, Linda, and his son, Jason, owned and operated the company.
During an interview, one DOH employee stated that he had seen Gary Kitzmiller in a DOH vehicle in other counties in the eastern panhandle, and had also observed Kitzmiller in a DOH vehicle on A.L.L. Construction Company construction sites during DOH work hours.
An employee at the Grant County DOH office stated that Gary Kitzmiller had directed employees 20 or more times to enter the DOH REMIS computer system and look up DOH Engineers’ construction cost estimates on projects that were being let out for bid. One employee was directed on July 12, 2004 to look up a DOH Engineer’s construction cost estimate and provide these figures to his son, Jason Kitzmiller. This bid was to be opened the next day in Charleston, West Virginia. This bid was won by
A.L.L. Construction Company.
Office employees of the DOH Grant County office advised investigators that they had observed Jason Kitzmiller using a State computer at the Petersburg DOH office five or more times.
Investigators interviewed an employee of the Region VIII Planning & Development Council, which was overseeing a sewer and water grant in Elk Garden, Mineral County, West Virginia. This individual stated on May 28, 2002, Gary Kitzmiller, who is personally known by this individual, came to a mandatory pre-bid and signed the sign-in sheet with his name and that he was representing A.L.L. Construction.
Investigators obtained the DOH time cards for May 28, 2002. Kitzmiller had reported that he had worked for the DOH on that day.
Investigators interviewed a Grant County DOH employee, who stated on June 1, 2004, he was clearing brush on a County highway and observed Gary Kitzmiller drive by in his DOH vehicle. The employee stated a few minutes later he observed Gary Kitzmiller driving his (Kitzmiller’s) personal logging truck, loaded with logs, past the same location. The individual stated approximately 30 to 40 minutes later, Gary Kitzmiller drove by the worksite again and the logs were no longer on the log truck. The individual stated that a little while later, Gary Kitzmiller was observed driving by the worksite again, however he (Kitzmiller) was in his DOH vehicle.
Investigators checked the employee time report for June 1, 2004. Gary Kitzmiller reported that he had worked 11 hours as a DOH Supervisor for June 1, 2004.
One DOH Project Engineer advised Investigators that on two separate occasions, while overseeing jobs in Grant and Hampshire Counties, he observed Gary Kitzmiller during normal DOH hours in a DOH vehicle delivering A.L.L Construction payroll checks to A.L.L. Construction employees.
Investigators obtained the DOH cellular telephone billings for the DOH cell phone assigned to Gary Kitzmiller. It was determined that approximately 60 to 70 percent of all calls made by Kitzmiller were to either the A.L.L. Construction business office or to cell phones assigned to A.L.L. Construction employees.
Investigators reviewed the West Virginia Unemployment Compensation Wage Reports for A.L.L. Construction from the first quarter of 2000 through the second quarter of 2004. These Compensation Wage Reports show the amount of money reported to West Virginia Unemployment. From the third quarter of 2001 to the end of the second quarter in 2004, A.L.L. Construction Company paid Gary Kitzmiller over $92,000. This was while he was a full-time employee of the State of West Virginia Division of Highways.
On February 15, 2005, a Report of Investigation was given to the Kanawha County Prosecutor’s Office. The Prosecutor’s Office is reviewing the report as of this writing.
Cynthia Dalton was employed by the Division of Highways (DOH) Department of Transportation (DOT) in District 10, Raleigh County, as an Office Assistant III. She began her employment on May 5, 1985 and resigned on July 31, 2003. At the time of
her resignation, she was aware that she was the subject of an investigation relating to her personal use of her State Purchasing Card. Dalton had been issued a State of West Virginia Purchasing Card to purchase goods and services of small dollar amounts for the DOH Raleigh County office.
Between August 3, 2001 and August 4, 2002, Dalton used her Purchasing Card to purchase over $13,300 of goods and services from Cintas Corporation, Ashland, Kentucky. Cintas provides entrance floor mats and hygiene services for DOH Raleigh County. During this period, a total of 40 purchasing transactions were made from Cintas by Cynthia Dalton. Included in the transactions are goods of a personal nature on 13 transactions totaling $6,827.94. A personal payment of $180 was made to Cynthia Dalton by another DOH employee in the County to reduce the value of the personal purchases to $6,647.94. The personal items were such things as women’s V-neck shirts ($18.99), with an emblem ($3.95 additional); T-shirts ($11.99), with an emblem ($3.95 additional); pro-knit shirt ($24.99), with emblem (additional $3.95); two-tone twill baseball cap ($12.99); next generation color block knit shirt ($27.99), with emblem (additional $3.95); baseball caps brushed twill ($11.99), with an emblem ($3.95 additional); light weight nylon jackets ($26.99), with emblem (additional $4.95); hooded sweatshirts ($24.99), with emblem (additional $4.95); three seasons jackets ($49.99), with an emblem (additional $3.25); pinpoint Oxford shirt ($36.99), with emblem (additional $4.95); jacket ($39.95), with emblem; a blanket lined duck jacket ($50.99), with emblem (additional $4.95); and a waterproof jacket ($59.99), with emblem (additional $3.95). In addition to these items, freight was charged for delivery.
During an interview of Cynthia Dalton, Dalton admitted she used her State Purchasing Card to make personal purchases from Cintas and failed to reimburse the State of West Virginia for the personal items. Dalton said she sold most of the items to other employees and their relatives. According to Dalton, some of the employees did not always pay her for the items. Dalton said she did not reimburse the State for the items that other employees had not paid her for. She also did not pay for items she purchased for her personal use.
On July 31, 2003, Cynthia Dalton resigned from her employment with the Division of Highways for personal reasons.
In November 2004, Cynthia Dalton was indicted by the Kanawha County Grand Jury to one count of Computer Fraud and two counts of Embezzlement.
In January 2005, Cynthia Dalton was given pre-trial diversion and ordered to pay $6,647.94 in restitution, which was paid on April 21, 2005.
In January 2003, the Commission on Special Investigations became aware of sales to the Division of Highways by a company named Stone Cold Chemicals. This information was obtained while the Commission on Special Investigations was investigating another DOH Purchasing card fraud case, which was reported in the 2002 Annual Report.
CSI Investigators, working in conjunction with the Georgia Bureau of Investigation and Florida Law Enforcement, were able to obtain records of Stone Cold Chemicals that reflected the company had mailed premiums or gratuities to Mr. Michael “Mickey” Knight’s home, totaling $3,499.99, beginning January 17, 2001 through December 12, 2002.
On many of the company records, which they called “catch reports”, there would be a list of products purchased and then there would be a blocked titled “Premiums”, which listed Mr. Knight’s home address, his name, and what type of premium he was to receive for placing the order. Premiums would range in amount, but would average approximately $100.00 per order and would vary from Wal-Mart, Sears and Outback Steakhouse gift certificates.
On November 10, 2003, Michael “Mickey” Knight plead guilty to Obtaining Money, etc., from the State by Fraud (5A-3-30) and Participating in a Corrupt Combination Collusion or Conspiracy (5A-3-31).
In January 2004, Michael Knight was sentenced to two years probation and ordered to pay $10,000 restitution.
In June 2004, Knight paid $10,000 in restitution.
In February 2005, the Commission received information of spending irregularities and mismanagement associated with millions of dollars in Federal Homeland Security funds. Among suspected activities were state employee personal use of state vehicles, purchasing and fuel cards as well as improper procurement of highly sophisticated and costly equipment and vehicles.
Through interviews and document review, Commission investigators identified several areas of interest. Documents from multiple state agencies were cross-referenced and a pattern of possible abuse of a state fuel purchasing card and vehicle were identified. This resulted in the expansion of the scope of the investigation and additional interviews and on site visits were made. An attempt to conduct a follow-up interview of the Director of the West Virginia Regional Response Program, Neil Sharp III, was preempted by Sharp’s resignation and relocation out of state.
The investigation continues with inquiries into state P-Card purchases, contract purchases, inaccurate and incomplete inventory records, improper equipment disbursements, and questionable sub-grant issuance.
In July 2003, a Commission investigator interviewed an inmate at the Mount Olive Correctional Complex. The inmate had written numerous letters to various State officials complaining of problems with the prison food services and medical services, allegations of nepotism by the prison administration, and irregularities in the prison Commissary. Information obtained during the interview contained no specifics of wrong doing associated with the food or medical services and the inmate had no specific examples of nepotism. The information regarding misuse of the Inmate Benefit Fund and improper operation of the prison Commissary were specific enough that the Commission investigator requested a meeting with Prison Warden Thomas McBride, where a request was made that the allegations be investigated internally.
Warden McBride ordered an investigation and the Commission investigator and a representative of the Post Audit Division met with prison officials to review the findings in August 2003. The prison report established that inmates assigned to the Commissary were smuggling goods from the Commissary and bartering them among the prison population. Disciplinary action was taken against the offenders.
During these meetings the Commissary Supervisor, Angela Carpenter, was interviewed by the Commission investigator and Post Audit representative. This interview disclosed numerous problems with Commissary operations. The Commission investigator suspected Carpenter was embezzling monies from the Commissary and/or making fraudulent entries in accounting ledgers. Warden McBride agreed to direct an audit of the Commissary funds.
Late in 2003, the Commission received a brief report from the prison. A copy of this report was also forwarded to the local detachment of the West Virginia State Police. This report confirmed Carpenter had embezzled in excess of $150,000. The Commission investigator contacted the West Virginia State Police and maintained contact with that agency until Carpenter was indicted and subsequently arrested in Ohio and extradited back to Fayette County to answer the indictment.
In late 2004, Carpenter entered into a plea agreement in Fayette County Circuit Court and was sentenced to 1-10 years in prison and ordered to pay $180,000 in restitution, plus court costs.
|Mission |||Commission Members |||Staff |||Annual Report |||CSI Main|